- 202 views
- 273 downloads
Was the Axiom of Reducibility a Principle of Logic?
-
- Author(s) / Creator(s)
-
THE TITLE OF this paper is in the past tense to indicate that the question it will address is whether the Axiom of Reducibility is a principle of logic according to the view of logic that Russell had when writing the first edition of Principia Mathematica.' It is often said that Logicism was a failure because when it avoided the Scylla of contradiction in Frege's system it fell into the Charybdis ofrequiring'obviously non-logical principles at Russell's hands. The axiom reducibility is cited along with the Axiom ofInfinity as a non-logical principle which Russell had to add to his system in order to be able to develop mathematics. I want to consider this criticism of the axiom from several points of view. Why is it thought that the axiom of reducibility is not a principle of logic? What reasons does Russell actually give for doubting its logical status? Are they good reasons?
-
- Date created
- 1990
-
- Subjects / Keywords
-
- Type of Item
- Article (Published)
-
- License
- © 1990 Bernard Linsky et al. This version of this article is open access and can be downloaded and shared. The original author(s) and source must be cited.